Halloween Fudge doesn’t have to be just black and orange. We’ve made a fun colorful version with pink, teal, and yellow of this vanilla chocolate fudge recipe.

pink, teal, yellow and black fudge squares on white plate

Colorful Halloween Fudge

Fudge is such an easy dessert and people think it’s hard to make. It’s not hard at all and with this colorful version you’ll have everyone asking how you made it!

It’s a simple process of melting white chocolate and sweetened condensed milk with some butter until it’s smooth. Then you’ll divide the mixture into parts and put gel food coloring in it.

Place blobs of each color randomly in the baking dish so that you get a cool design pattern when the fudge hardens. It’s so fun and it will be unique every time you make it!

If you love a good fudge recipe for Halloween, you might also want to try our candy cane fudge.

Ingredients

white chocolate chips
sweetened condensed milk
butter
vanilla
gel food coloring (we used black, yellow, pink, and teal)

Instructions

four photos of the process: glass baking dish lined with wax paper; sauce pan with ingredients being melted; melted white fudge in sauce pan; teal, black, yellow, and pink fudge mixture in baking dish

Line a 8×8 square pan with parchment paper
Add the chocolate chips, milk, and butter into a medium pot over low to medium heat
Stir mixture until melted
Stir in the pure vanilla extract
Divide the fudge into 4 small bowls
Mix in a few drops of each color into 1 bowl each
Alternate between the four colors by dropping a tablespoon of each color into the square pan Allow the fudge to harden overnight before cutting into two-inch squares

colorful fudge squares on white plate with potion books in background

Tips

Line the pan – be sure to line the pan so you can pull the entire fudge piece out and cut on a table.
Chill time – let it cool completely
Sharp knife – use a sharp knife to get clean lines
Gel food coloring – since this recipe relies heavily on bright colors it’s best to use gel food colorings. The traditional food coloring drops won’t give you the same deep colors.

Alternatives

This is such a fun recipe and you can switch it up pretty easily to fit different themes.

Valentine’s Day – use red and pink food coloring and keep one part white chocolate to make a pretty pattern for Valentine’s day.
Christmas – use red, green and white. You could also add peppermint extract.
Halloween – orange, black and purple – this would also be a great combo for Halloween.
St. Patrick’s Day – green, black, and white. Add mint extract too.

Want More Fun Halloween Treats?

pink, teal, yellow, and black fudge squares

Colorful Halloween Fudge

Course Dessert

Cuisine American

Prep Time 15

Chill time 4

Total Time 4 15

Halloween Fudge doesn't have to be just black and orange. We've made a fun colorful version with pink, teal, and yellow of this vanilla chocolate fudge recipe.

Ingredients

▢ 3 cups white chocolate chips
▢ 1 – 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk
▢ 4 Tbsp butter
▢ 1 tsp vanilla extract
▢ gel food coloring yellow, pink, teal, and black

Instructions

Line a 8×8 square pan with parchment paper
Add the chocolate chips, milk, and butter into a medium pot over low to medium heat
3 cups white chocolate chips, 1 – 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk, 4 Tbsp butter
Stir mixture until melted
Stir in the pure vanilla extract
1 tsp vanilla extract
Divide the fudge into 4 small bowls
Mix in a few drops of each color into 1 bowl each
gel food coloring
Alternate between the four colors by dropping a tablespoon of each color into the square pan Allow the fudge to harden overnight before cutting into 2in squares